Creating an Email Marketing Plan: A Step-by-Step Guide



Sep 18, 2023


min read

Digital marketing is always changing — but email marketing remains a constant, reliable pillar in building customer loyalty,brand awareness, and, most importantly, sales!

Email marketing is essential in your marketing toolkit, enabling direct communication with your audience, providing personalized content, and nurturing leads into loyal customers. Simply stated, email marketing is powerful, personal, and profitable when it’s done right.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through creating a winning email marketing strategy. You'll learn how to build a targeted email list, create compelling content, utilize templates and automation, integrate your efforts with other marketing channels, track your success through key metrics, and optimize your campaigns for the best results.

Understanding and implementing email marketing can significantly boost your brand's success, whether you're a small business or a large enterprise.

What Are the Key Terms in Email Marketing?

To master email marketing, it's essential to understand the key terminology associated with it.

One of the fundamental terms is email segmentation. This is the practice of dividing your email list into specific segments based on criteria such as demographics, customer behavior, or purchase history. Segmentation allows you to send targeted, personalized emails, increasing engagement and conversion rates.

A good email subject line is another crucial element. It's the first thing your subscribers see and can significantly impact your open rate – the percentage of recipients who open your email. Your subject line should be compelling and give a glimpse of what the email contains.

Another important term is the click-through rate (CTR). CTR refers to the percentage of recipients who clicked on one or more of the links in your email. A high CTR indicates that your email content is engaging and relevant to your audience.

Deliverability is another key term that refers to whether your emails successfully reach your subscribers’ inboxes without being flagged as spam. High deliverability is crucial for the success of your email marketing campaigns, as it ensures that your emails are reaching your audience.

How Do You Build a Target Email List?

The first step towards a successful email marketing campaign is creating a strategic plan. Defining clear, measurable goals forms the foundation of an effective email marketing strategy.

Are you aiming to boost brand awareness or promote a new product? Maybe your focus is on re-engaging inactive subscribers or fostering customer loyalty. Each goal has unique implications for your campaign structure and content, and it provides a benchmark against which you can measure success.

Next, it's essential to identify your target audience. Are they new customers, or are you focusing on existing ones? What are their interests, and how does your product or service cater to these needs? Understanding your audience demographic and psychographic profiles allows you to tailor your email content, enhancing relevance and engagement.

The cornerstone of successful email marketing is the email list. Building a high-quality email list – filled with subscribers genuinely interested in your brand – is not just an added advantage but a necessity.

Consider using ethical opt-in methods to collect email addresses. These could include sign-up forms on your landing pages, enticing pop-ups on your site, or engaging lead magnets.

Remember, compliance with GDPR and CAN-SPAM regulations is crucial for ethical and legal email marketing practices. More details on these regulations later.

How Do You Create Effective Email Content?

Email marketing is versatile, offering a broad spectrum of email types, each serving a unique purpose in your email marketing plan.

Understanding the different types of emails and their uses will help you create a more effective email marketing strategy:

• Welcome emails are typically the first point of contact and are triggered as soon as new subscribersopt in. They set the tone for future communications and offer an excellent opportunity to introduce your brand ethos and its offerings, thus building brand awareness.

• Promotional emailsare designed with a clear objective: to drive sales. These emails highlight specific products, services, or offers, such as launching a new product or announcing a limited-time coupon. They include a compelling call to action (CTA) that prompts subscribers to make a purchase, visit your site, or learn more about the offer.

• Email newsletters, sent out regularly, provide valuable content to your subscribers. They can contain a mix of content, including industry insights, company updates, or upcoming webinars, fostering a sense of community and engagement.

• Transactional emails, such as order confirmations or shipping notifications, are action-triggered. These are integral for ecommerce businesses, keeping customers informed and engaged during their buying journey.

• Re-engagement emails target subscribers who have been inactive. These emails could serve as a gentle reminder of your brand's value or offer an exclusive incentive to bring them back into the engagement fold.

Quick Tips for Email Marketing

When generating the email itself, it’s important to remember that content is king. Quality content can be the difference between an email that drives conversion and one destined for the trash bin.

Here are a few tips that can help you create an email that won’t be immediately thrown away:

Start with a compelling subject line – it's the first thing your subscribers see, and a good email subject line can significantly improve your open rate. Make it engaging, relevant, and concise. Personalization, such as using the recipient's name, can enhance the impact of your subject line.

The body of the email should deliver on the promise of the subject line. Keep your content concise and easy to read. Use headers and bullet points to break up the text, making it digestible for readers. Most importantly, ensure your content provides value to your subscribers – be it through informative articles, exclusive offers, or updates about your brand.

The design of your email is equally crucial. An aesthetically pleasing design can grab your subscribers' attention and keep them engaged. Use images and graphics strategically – they should support your content, not distract from it.

Also, don't forget about mobile devices — with a large number of emails now opened on smartphones and tablets, optimizing your email design for mobile is an absolute must.

How Do You Utilize Advanced Tools in Email Marketing?

Having the right tools is crucial to executing a successful email marketing strategy. Using them properly can help you better engage with your email subscribers and reach potential customers.

Here are a few examples of the most useful advanced tools in email marketing:


The role of automation in email marketing cannot be overstated. It's a game-changer that allows you to streamline processes, maintain consistency, and deliver timely content to your audience. Let's explore how automation and advanced tools can amplify email marketing efforts.

Email automation refers to the process of sending out emails to your subscribers automatically, based on a schedule or specific triggers. For instance, you can set up an automated welcome email sequence for new subscribers or an automated email for customers who abandon their shopping cart.

One of the key benefits of email automation is the ability to nurture leads effectively. With automated follow-up emails, you can guide your subscribers through the sales funnel without manually sending each email. This saves time and ensures that you’re regularly communicating with your subscribers, thereby increasing the chances of conversion.

Additionally, automation allows for better personalization. With tools that integrate with your customer relationship management (CRM), you can segment your email list based on various factors such as customer behavior, demographics, or past interactions. This allows for more targeted and relevant email content, leading to higher engagement rates.


Segmentation is a technique that divides your email list into smaller, more targeted groups based on specific criteria, such as demographics, buying behavior, or previous interactions with your brand. This practice is a key element of marketing automation, and it allows for more personalized and relevant email marketing campaigns.

For instance, a clothing retailer might segment their email list by gender, location, or purchase history to send tailored product recommendations. A B2B company might segment by industry, job title, or stage in the sales funnel to send more relevant content.

Utilizing advanced tools for segmentation not only helps you send the best email for each subscriber, but also improves your email open rates and click-through rates, thereby enhancing the overall success of your email marketing efforts.

A/B Testing

A/B testing is another advanced tool that is essential for improving your email marketing performance. This involves creating two versions of your email — each with a single difference — to see which performs better. For instance, you might test two different subject lines, email templates, or call-to-action (CTA) placements.

This method provides valuable insight into what resonates with your audience and what doesn’t. The data derived from A/B testing can then be used to optimize future email campaigns, aligning them more effectively with your email marketing goals.

Remember, A/B testing isn't a one-time event; it's a continuous process of learning and improving.

Email Service Providers (ESPs)

Choosing the right email service provider is critical in your email marketing strategy. ESPs offer a platform for managing your email list, creating and sending email campaigns, and analyzing their performance.

Many ESPs offer a variety of email templates, which can save you time and help maintain a consistent, professional look across your email campaigns. They also offer tools for content marketing, allowing you to create, schedule, and manage your email content efficiently. For a higher degree of customization and a more sophisticated email design, you may want to consider working with a company that specializes in email marketing.

One of the most valuable features of an ESP is its analytics capabilities. These provide insights into your email open rates, click-through rates, and other key metrics — which, in turn, helps you measure how successful your campaigns are, then make data-driven decisions accordingly.

When selecting an ESP, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind:

1. Ensure that the platform supports the advanced tools you need, such as segmentation and A/B testing.

2. Consider the ease of use and the quality of the customer support.

3. Evaluate the pricing options to ensure they align with your budget and offer value for your investment.

4. Choose an ESP that has existing integrations to your other platforms — like Shopify or Postscript.

How Do You Integrate Email Marketing With Other Marketing Channels?

While email marketing is a powerful tool in its own right, it becomes even more potent when integrated with other marketing channels. This multi-channel approach ensures a consistent and seamless experience for your audience, wherever they interact with your brand.

Social media and email marketing are two channels that intersect perfectly. Promoting your email newsletter on your social platforms can attract new subscribers, while including social sharing buttons in your emails encourages subscribers to engage with your brand on social media. In turn, social media can provide valuable insights into your audience's interests and behaviors, helping you tailor your email content.

Synergy also exists between paid ads and email marketing. With an optimized email capture strategy in place on the website, there’s a higher chance of capturing first-party data from traffic being driven by paid ads. Then, those users can be retargeted with email for a higher chance of converting.

Landing pages play a critical role in email marketing campaigns. When subscribers click on a CTA in your email, they should be directed to a landing page that aligns with the email's message. This ensures a consistent experience and increases the likelihood of conversion.

Webinars can also synergize with email marketing. You can use emails to promote upcoming webinars, follow up with attendees, or share recordings with those who couldn't attend. This adds value for your subscribers and further engages them with your brand.

For ecommerce businesses, email marketing is a lifeline. It can drive sales through promotional emails, cart abandonment reminders, and transactional emails. Moreover, personalized product recommendations based on a subscriber's past purchases can significantly boost conversion rates.

How Do You Track the Overall Success of Your Campaign?

Understanding and tracking the right metrics is crucial to the success of your email marketing efforts.

Key performance indicators (KPIs) like open rate, click-through rate, conversion rates, and bounce rate provide a snapshot of your campaign's performance:

• The open rate indicates the percentage of subscribers who opened your email, which can signal the effectiveness of your subject lines — just take this data with a grain of salt, as other KPIs may provide more reliable information.

• The click-through rate reveals how many subscribers clicked on a link within your email, reflecting the effectiveness of your content and CTAs.

• Conversion rates tell you how many of those clicks resulted in the desired action, such as a purchase or sign-up.

• The bounce rate shows the percentage of emails that weren't delivered, which can indicate issues with your email list's quality or your email's deliverability.

However, tracking these metrics isn't enough – you must also optimize your campaigns based on your findings. For instance, if your emails have a low open rate, you might need to improve your subject lines. If your click-through rate is low, revisiting your email content or CTAs could be necessary.

Re-engagement strategies for inactive subscribers, such as sending win-back emails or offering exclusive deals, can help improve engagement and reduce your unsubscribe rate. Understanding email deliverability – the ability of your emails to reach the inbox – is also critical. Improving your sender reputation, segmenting your list, and regularly cleaning your email list are all strategies that can enhance your email deliverability.

Are There Any Legal or Ethical Considerations for Email Marketing?

Navigating the digital marketing world necessitates a keen understanding of the legal and ethical boundaries in place. This is especially true for email marketing, where regulations like CAN-SPAM and GDPR can heavily influence your strategy.

The CAN-SPAM Act sets the rules for commercial email and gives recipients the right to stop businesses from emailing them. It outlines requirements for commercial messages and spells out penalties for violations.

GDPR, or the General Data Protection Regulation, is a European law that regulates how businesses collect, use, and store personal data, including email addresses.

Respecting user privacy goes beyond mere legal compliance — it's a matter of establishing trust with your customers. Always provide clear opt-in and opt-out options, never purchase email lists, and be transparent about subscriber data use.

Best practices for ethical email marketing also include regular list cleaning to remove inactive subscribers, ensuring your emails are accessible to people with disabilities, and maintaining a balanced ratio of promotional to educational content.

Remember, ethical email marketing isn't just about avoiding penalties, but building lasting relationships with your subscribers.

The Bottom Line

By now, you should have a firm grasp of the importance of email marketing in the broader context of digital marketing. It's more than just sending out newsletters; it's about building relationships with your audience, understanding their needs, and providing value through your content.

Creating an effective email marketing strategy may seem daunting, but with the right approach and continuous optimization, you can successfully engage your audience and achieve your business goals.

Remember, the key to email marketing success lies in delivering the right message to the right person at the right time. Keep learning, keep testing, and keep optimizing. Your email marketing success is just around the corner.

While you’re at it, it might be worthwhile to consider hiring an SEO agency to help with your email marketing campaign. SEO can help your content rank higher up in search engine results, while email marketing places them directly into your subscribers' inboxes. The combination can prove extremely valuable when used properly.

If you’re looking for more information about how SEO can help your email marketing campaign, then schedule a consultation with GR0 today. You can review our case studies here to see why we’ve become one of the fastest-growing digital marketing agencies in the country. Together we can help “GR0” your business to reach its full potential!


What is Email Marketing? | Western Governors University

Click-Through Rate (CTR): Definition, Formula, and Analysis | Investopedia

What Is A Target Audience And How Do You Find It | Search Engine Journal

9 Strategies For Email Marketing Segmentation | TechTarget

What Is CRM? Customer Relationship Management Defined | Investopedia

A Refresher on A/B Testing | Harvard Business Review

Email Service Providers: 8 Most Popular Email Providers | Mailchimp

Key Performance Indicator (KPI): Definition, Types, and Examples | Investopedia

CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business | Federal Trade Commission

What Is GDPR, The EU’s New Data Protection Law? | GDPR


Case Studies